Middle Island, NY Real Estate & Property Data
Accurate and comprehensive real estate data is critical for insight into Middle Island, NY 11953. ATTOM’s Middle Island real estate data is updated daily, and current market trends show that in Middle Island, NY a total of 245 residential properties have sold over the past year. With a median home price of $400,000 in Middle Island and a total of 2 foreclosures. Get detailed property data for Middle Island, NY instantly. ATTOM is your one-stop-shop for the Middle Island property reports and real estate data you need in Middle Island, NY.
Middle Island, NY 11953 Real Estate Overview
There were 245 residential properties sold in the past year in Middle Island, NY 11953. The median home value in Middle Island, NY 11953 is $480,000. There are a total of 4,262 residential properties in the 11953.
- June '25 Jun '25 $400,000
- May '25 May '25 $460,000
- April '25 Apr '25 $495,000
- March '25 Mar '25 $515,000
- February '25 Feb '25 $464,950
- January '25 Jan '25 $525,000
- December '24 Dec '24 $358,000
- November '24 Nov '24 $467,500
- October '24 Oct '24 $475,000
- September '24 Sep '24 $580,000
- August '24 Aug '24 $490,000
- July '24 Jul '24 $500,000
- June '25 Jun '25 $388,000
- May '25 May '25 $61,753
- April '25 Apr '25 $112,625
- March '25 Mar '25 $75,000
- February '25 Feb '25 $88,000
- January '25 Jan '25 $78,750
- December '24 Dec '24 $59,250
- November '24 Nov '24 $159,000
- October '24 Oct '24 $131,985
- September '24 Sep '24 $75,000
- August '24 Aug '24 $91,500
- July '24 Jul '24 $59,000
Middle Island, NY 11953 Foreclosure Activity
There were a total of 2 Middle Island, NY 11953 properties with a foreclosure filing in June 2025.
Contact Us Now!
Call (800) 692-2596 — or fill out this form and we’ll be in touch shortly.